# Reverting an existing commit

One of the changes I pulled into the master branch turns out to break building GIT with GCC 2.95. While they were well intentioned portability fixes, keeping things working with gcc-2.95 was also important. Here is what I did to revert the change in the master branch and to adjust the pu branch, using core GIT tools and barebone Porcelain.

First, prepare a throw-away branch in case I screw things up.

    $ git checkout -b revert-c99 master

Now I am on the revert-c99 branch. Let's figure out which commit to revert. I happen to know that the top of the master branch is a merge, and its second parent (i.e. foreign commit I merged from) has the change I would want to undo. Further I happen to know that that merge introduced 5 commits or so:

    $ git show-branch --more=4 master master^2 | head
    * [master] Merge refs/heads/portable from http://www.cs.berkeley....
     ! [master^2] Replace C99 array initializers with code.
    --
    -  [master] Merge refs/heads/portable from http://www.cs.berkeley....
    *+ [master^2] Replace C99 array initializers with code.
    *+ [master^2~1] Replace unsetenv() and setenv() with older putenv().
    *+ [master^2~2] Include sys/time.h in daemon.c.
    *+ [master^2~3] Fix ?: statements.
    *+ [master^2~4] Replace zero-length array decls with [].
    *  [master~1] tutorial note about git branch

The —more=4 above means "after we reach the merge base of refs, show until we display four more common commits". That last commit would have been where the "portable" branch was forked from the main git.git repository, so this would show everything on both branches since then. I just limited the output to the first handful using head.

Now I know master^2~4 (pronounce it as "find the second parent of the master, and then go four generations back following the first parent") is the one I would want to revert. Since I also want to say why I am reverting it, the -n flag is given to git revert. This prevents it from actually making a commit, and instead git revert leaves the commit log message it wanted to use in .msg file:

    $ git revert -n master^2~4
    $ cat .msg
    Revert "Replace zero-length array decls with []."

    This reverts 6c5f9baa3bc0d63e141e0afc23110205379905a4 commit.
    $ git diff HEAD ;# to make sure what we are reverting makes sense.
    $ make CC=gcc-2.95 clean test ;# make sure it fixed the breakage.
    $ make clean test ;# make sure it did not cause other breakage.

The reverted change makes sense (from reading the diff output), does fix the problem (from make CC=gcc-2.95 test), and does not cause new breakage (from the last make test). I'm ready to commit:

    $ git commit -a -s ;# read .msg into the log,
                        # and explain why I am reverting.

I could have screwed up in any of the above steps, but in the worst case I could just have done git checkout master to start over. Fortunately I did not have to; what I have in the current branch revert-c99 is what I want. So merge that back into master:

    $ git checkout master
    $ git merge revert-c99 ;# this should be a fast forward
    Updating from 10d781b9caa4f71495c7b34963bef137216f86a8 to e3a693c...
     cache.h        |    8 ++++----
     commit.c       |    2 +-
     ls-files.c     |    2 +-
     receive-pack.c |    2 +-
     server-info.c  |    2 +-
     5 files changed, 8 insertions(+), 8 deletions(-)

There is no need to redo the test at this point. We fast forwarded and we know master matches revert-c99 exactly. In fact:

    $ git diff master..revert-c99

says nothing.

Then we rebase the pu branch as usual.

    $ git checkout pu
    $ git tag pu-anchor pu
    $ git rebase master
    * Applying: Redo "revert" using three-way merge machinery.
    First trying simple merge strategy to cherry-pick.
    Finished one cherry-pick.
    * Applying: Remove git-apply-patch-script.
    First trying simple merge strategy to cherry-pick.
    Simple cherry-pick fails; trying Automatic cherry-pick.
    Removing Documentation/git-apply-patch-script.txt
    Removing git-apply-patch-script
    Finished one cherry-pick.
    * Applying: Document "git cherry-pick" and "git revert"
    First trying simple merge strategy to cherry-pick.
    Finished one cherry-pick.
    * Applying: mailinfo and applymbox updates
    First trying simple merge strategy to cherry-pick.
    Finished one cherry-pick.
    * Applying: Show commits in topo order and name all commits.
    First trying simple merge strategy to cherry-pick.
    Finished one cherry-pick.
    * Applying: More documentation updates.
    First trying simple merge strategy to cherry-pick.
    Finished one cherry-pick.

The temporary tag pu-anchor is me just being careful, in case git rebase screws up. After this, I can do these for sanity check:

    $ git diff pu-anchor..pu ;# make sure we got the master fix.
    $ make CC=gcc-2.95 clean test ;# make sure it fixed the breakage.
    $ make clean test ;# make sure it did not cause other breakage.

Everything is in the good order. I do not need the temporary branch nor tag anymore, so remove them:

    $ rm -f .git/refs/tags/pu-anchor
    $ git branch -d revert-c99

It was an emergency fix, so we might as well merge it into the release candidate branch, although I expect the next release would be some days off:

    $ git checkout rc
    $ git pull . master
    Packing 0 objects
    Unpacking 0 objects

    * committish: e3a693c...        refs/heads/master from .
    Trying to merge e3a693c... into 8c1f5f0... using 10d781b...
    Committed merge 7fb9b7262a1d1e0a47bbfdcbbcf50ce0635d3f8f
     cache.h        |    8 ++++----
     commit.c       |    2 +-
     ls-files.c     |    2 +-
     receive-pack.c |    2 +-
     server-info.c  |    2 +-
     5 files changed, 8 insertions(+), 8 deletions(-)

And the final repository status looks like this:

    $ git show-branch --more=1 master pu rc
    ! [master] Revert "Replace zero-length array decls with []."
     ! [pu] git-repack: Add option to repack all objects.
      * [rc] Merge refs/heads/master from .
    ---
     +  [pu] git-repack: Add option to repack all objects.
     +  [pu~1] More documentation updates.
     +  [pu~2] Show commits in topo order and name all commits.
     +  [pu~3] mailinfo and applymbox updates
     +  [pu~4] Document "git cherry-pick" and "git revert"
     +  [pu~5] Remove git-apply-patch-script.
     +  [pu~6] Redo "revert" using three-way merge machinery.
      - [rc] Merge refs/heads/master from .
    ++* [master] Revert "Replace zero-length array decls with []."
      - [rc~1] Merge refs/heads/master from .
    ... [master~1] Merge refs/heads/portable from http://www.cs.berkeley....